CA License #995715
Open Hours: Mon-Fri 8:00AM - 5:00PM
Asphalt Parking lot

Five Materials for Building a Parking Lot: A Comprehensive Guide

EARTHTEKJuly 6, 2023

Whether you're considering developing a parking lot for a business, residential area, or public infrastructure, selecting the suitable material can be a game-changer. This decision can affect the durability, cost, maintenance, and even the aesthetic appeal of the lot. To help you navigate this crucial decision-making process, we've compiled a guide that delves into five popular materials for constructing parking lots: asphalt, concrete, gravel, tar & chip, and permeable pavers.

Each material boasts unique features, installation methods, advantages, and disadvantages, making them suitable for different applications. Our guide will provide a comprehensive overview of each type, from installation to pros and cons, offering the necessary information to determine the best fit for your project.

Concrete Parking Lots

A synonym for strength and durability in the construction industry, concrete often emerges as a reliable choice for both commercial parking lots and residential concrete driveways. With its exceptional ability to withstand heavy traffic, weather extremes, and years of wear and tear, a concrete parking lot is an investment that pays off in the long run.

The installation process is crucial to achieving the strength and longevity associated with concrete, and this is where a commercial concrete company comes into play. Armed with the right expertise and tools, these professionals ensure the correct procedures are followed, paving the way for a sturdy and reliable parking area. Let's delve deeper into the specifics of using concrete for parking lots, examining its installation, pros, and cons.

aerial view of a concrete parking lot

Pros of Concrete Parking Lots

Durability: One of the most significant benefits of concrete for a parking lot is its durability. Concrete is incredibly resilient and can withstand heavy vehicles and frequent traffic, making it an excellent choice for high-traffic areas or industrial areas with heavy semi-truck traffic.

Longevity: Concrete lots typically have a long lifespan, often outlasting other materials. Proper maintenance means a concrete parking lot can last up to 30-40 years.

Heat Reflection: In San Jose, we don’t have to be overly concerned with high temperatures, but unlike asphalt, which absorbs heat, concrete reflects it. This property makes concrete a cooler choice in warmer climates and can help reduce the 'heat island' effect in urban areas.

Very Low Maintenance: Once a concrete lot is installed and cured, it requires relatively low maintenance. Occasional cleaning, sealing, and minor crack repair can keep the lot looking good and functioning well for many years.

Eco-friendly: Concrete is a sustainable option as it's made from abundant natural resources. Moreover, it's recyclable; old concrete can be crushed and reused in new construction projects.

Versatility: Concrete's versatility is another noteworthy benefit. It can be stamped or colored to match a variety of aesthetics, enabling you to customize the look of your parking lot. This is a great option when wanting to “dress up” the entrance to a hotel or restaurant.

Cons of Concrete Parking Lots

Cost: While concrete's durability and longevity are significant advantages, these benefits come with a higher upfront cost. The material and labor costs for installing a concrete parking lot can be more than other options like asphalt or gravel.

Installation Time: Concrete installation and curing process is longer than other materials. This means your parking lot will be out of commission for a longer period during construction.

Repair Time: While concrete requires less frequent maintenance when repairs are needed, they can be more complex and time-consuming. Concrete often requires large sections to be replaced rather than small spot repairs.

Repair Costs: When concrete needs to be repaired, it typically requires large sections to be removed and replaced. The labor, materials and downtime can be costly.

Cold Weather Challenges: In areas with harsh winters, concrete can be susceptible to damage from freeze-thaw cycles and deicing salts, which can cause surface scaling and cracking.

Stains and Discoloration: Concrete can be susceptible to staining from oil leaks and other vehicle fluids. Over time, these stains can lead to unsightly discoloration, detracting from the lot's aesthetic appeal.

Asphalt Parking Lots

Asphalt is the most common choice for parking lot construction, renowned for its balance of cost-effectiveness, durability, and flexibility. It's a material you'll frequently see under the wheels of your vehicle, be it at your local grocery store, office, or even at home. The task of installing an asphalt parking lot typically falls under the expertise of a San Jose paving company.

A commercial paving company possesses the knowledge and equipment necessary to ensure asphalt is laid down properly, creating a durable and well-structured parking area. Asphalt comes with its own set of unique advantages and potential drawbacks.

Asphalt Parking lot

Pros of Asphalt Parking Lots

Cost-Effective: Asphalt is typically less expensive than concrete in terms of material cost and installation, making it a more budget-friendly option for many.

Quick Installation: A professional paving company can install an asphalt parking lot relatively quickly, minimizing disruption to your business or property.

Easy to Repair: Maintenance and repairs are generally more straightforward with asphalt. Small cracks and potholes can often be filled and sealed without requiring a full replacement of the section.

Flexibility: Asphalt is a flexible material that can better handle temperature and ground movement changes, reducing the risk of cracking compared to more rigid materials like concrete.

Recyclable: Asphalt is 100% recyclable. When an asphalt parking lot reaches the end of its life, it can be milled and recycled to produce new asphalt, contributing to sustainability efforts.

Winter Friendly: It hasn’t snowed in San Jose since 1976, but our friends to the north benefit from asphalt because it retains heat, which helps snow and ice melt faster in the winter months. This makes maintenance easier in colder climates.

Cons of Asphalt Parking Lots

Lifespan: Despite being less expensive upfront, asphalt parking lots generally have a shorter lifespan than concrete. They typically last 20-25 years with proper maintenance, compared to the 30-40 years expected of concrete lots.

Load Restrictions: Asphalt will crack or rut under constant heavy loads unless specifically designed to carry heavy loads. It is possible to design asphalt parking lots to carry the weight of a semi-truck, but installing concrete to withstand these loads is more cost-effective.

Maintenance: While repairs are relatively easy, asphalt requires regular maintenance, including commercial sealcoating every 2-3 years to prevent water infiltration and prolong its lifespan.

Heat Absorption: Asphalt absorbs more heat than concrete due to its dark color, which can contribute to the urban heat island effect and make the parking lot surface hot during the summer months.

Aesthetics: Some may view asphalt's uniform black surface as less visually appealing than other materials. It doesn't offer the color or patterning versatility that materials like concrete or pavers do.

Susceptibility to Oil Stains: Asphalt is susceptible to oil stains, which can degrade the asphalt over time and create visually unattractive surface spots.

Gravel Parking Lots

Gravel stands out as an unconventional yet appealing choice for parking lots, particularly large open spaces, or for temporary parking solutions. This material brings together affordability and ease of installation.

A gravel parking lot does not require the extensive groundwork of asphalt or concrete, it still takes careful preparation. A grading contractor typically oversees this process, ensuring a level and properly drained foundation before the gravel is laid. The gravel used in parking lots can come in various sizes, shapes, and colors, but generally, it's small enough to be compacted into a stable surface yet large enough to allow for proper drainage.

Pros of Gravel Parking Lots

Affordability: Gravel is one of the most affordable materials for a parking lot. Both the material itself and the installation costs are low.

Quick Installation: A gravel parking lot can often be installed very quickly. Once the area has been graded, the gravel can be spread and compacted in a relatively short time frame.

Drainage: Gravel provides excellent drainage, as water can easily pass through the spaces between the stones. This can reduce problems with standing water or runoff.

Low Maintenance: Unlike asphalt and concrete parking lots, which can crack and need sealing, gravel lots simply need occasional grading to remain smooth and level.

Flexibility: Gravel lots can be easily expanded, reduced, or changed in shape to meet evolving needs.

Eco-friendly: Gravel parking lots are more permeable than asphalt or concrete, reducing runoff and making them a more environmentally friendly choice.

Cons of Gravel Parking Lots

Dust and Debris: Gravel parking lots can generate dust during dry conditions and may scatter small stones, potentially posing a nuisance or even a hazard.

Snow Removal: In climates with snow, removing it from gravel can be challenging without displacing the gravel itself.

Regular Maintenance: Gravel lots may require more frequent maintenance compared to other materials, such as regrading to fix potholes or to keep the surface level, as well as replenishing the gravel periodically.

Limited Lifespan: While individual stones can last a long time, a gravel lot as a whole has a limited lifespan before it requires replenishment due to gravel washing away and sinking.

Mobility Issues: For bicycles, wheelchairs, or other mobility devices, a gravel surface can be more difficult to navigate compared to smooth surfaces like asphalt or concrete.

Chip & Seal Parking Lots

Often considered the middle ground between asphalt and gravel parking lots, Chip and Seal, also known as "Tar & Chip," offers a blend of durability, cost-effectiveness, and aesthetic appeal. This technique combines the strength and stability of asphalt with the natural beauty of stone, resulting in a parking lot that is both practical and visually appealing.

The process involves applying a layer of hot liquid asphalt to a prepared base before spreading loose stones (chips) over the top. The stones are then compacted into the asphalt and left to cure, resulting in a rough, durable surface that offers excellent traction.

Close up of a chip and seal parking lot.

Pros of Chip & Seal Parking Lots

Aesthetics: Tar and chip parking lots provide a more natural, gravel-like appearance, which can be more appealing in certain settings. They can also be customized with different types and colors of stones for a unique look.

Cost-Effective: Tar and chip are generally less expensive than a traditional asphalt or concrete lot, offering a more budget-friendly yet still durable option.

Traction: The rough surface of a tar and chip lot provides excellent traction, even in wet conditions, making it a safe choice for all types of vehicles.

Low Maintenance: Tar and chip parking lots require less maintenance than asphalt. There's no need for regular sealing, as the stones and tar naturally resist damage from the sun and elements.

Durability: These lots are known for their durability. They're resistant to heavy loads and can handle substantial wear and tear without degrading.

Heat Resistance: Unlike asphalt, which can become soft in intense heat, tar and chip retains its structure and won't become tacky or sticky on hot days.

Cons of Tar and Chip Parking Lots

Rough Surface: The surface of a tar and chip lot is rougher than asphalt or concrete. This can make it less suitable for activities like biking, skateboarding, or for those using mobility aids.

Resurfacing Frequency: While maintenance is generally low, tar and chip parking lots do require resurfacing more frequently than asphalt or concrete ones – approximately every 7-10 years.

Oil Stains: Similar to asphalt, oil and other fluids can leave visible stains on the surface of tar and chip parking lots.

Inconsistent Appearance Over Time: Over time, as the surface wears down, a tar and chip lot may present a less consistent appearance compared to asphalt or concrete.

Best for low High Traffic: Although tar and chip serve well for areas with lighter traffic, it may pose challenges in places with high traffic density. Constant or heavy usage can displace the embedded chips, resulting in an uneven surface that may compromise safety.

Noisy: Tar and chip surfaces can be quite noisy when driven over. This can increase noise pollution, especially in residential or commercial areas where quiet is valued.

Permeable Pavers for Parking Lots

Permeable pavers are a solution that is visually appealing, highly durable, and environmentally conscious. These innovative paving solutions offer a way to build parking lots that are functional and attractive and contribute positively to the environment by managing stormwater runoff.

Permeable pavers, also known as porous or pervious pavers, are designed to allow rainwater to seep through the surface of the parking lot and into the ground below, reducing the impact on local drainage systems and minimizing water pollution. They are typically constructed from concrete, stone, and recycled plastic. For low-volume and temporary parking areas, grass can be used.

Working with permeable pavers requires special expertise, usually offered by a professional paving contractor with experience in eco-friendly solutions. While this material might not be as widely recognized as asphalt or concrete, it offers a host of unique benefits and considerations that could make it the ideal choice for your next parking lot project.

Pros of Permeable Pavers

Environmental Sustainability: Permeable pavers allow rainwater to seep into the ground, reducing runoff and recharging groundwater levels. This aids in the prevention of erosion and flooding and decreases the load on sewer systems during heavy rain.

Aesthetically Pleasing: Permeable pavers come in a wide range of styles, shapes, and colors, making it easy to create a parking lot that's both functional and visually appealing. They can be arranged in various patterns to add a distinctive look to your parking lot.

Low Maintenance: Permeable pavers require minimal maintenance. Routine sweeping to remove debris from the joints is usually sufficient to maintain permeability.

Heat Island Reduction: Unlike asphalt, which can absorb and radiate heat, permeable pavers help mitigate the urban heat island effect, contributing to a cooler environment.

Long-term Cost Efficiency: Although the initial investment might be higher, the long lifespan and low maintenance of permeable pavers can make them cost-effective over the long term.

Cons of Permeable Pavers

Initial Cost: Permeable pavers tend to be more expensive to install than traditional asphalt or concrete due to their intricate installation process and the need for specialized materials and expertise.

Susceptibility to Clogging: Over time, the small voids that allow water to permeate can become clogged with debris or sediment. If not addressed, this can compromise the pavers' permeability.

Potential for Weed Growth: The gaps between pavers might encourage the growth of weeds if not appropriately maintained.

Specialized Installation: Installing permeable pavers requires skilled labor and attention to detail, particularly to ensure proper grading and the integration of a suitable base layer for effective water drainage.

Not Suitable for Heavy Loads: While permeable pavers can handle regular vehicle traffic, they might not be suitable for areas with very heavy vehicles or extremely high traffic volume.

Climate Considerations: In colder climates, freeze and thaw cycles can impact the longevity and effectiveness of the permeable system.

Soil Issues: Permeable pavers may not be suitable for all types of soil. Heavy clay soils or those that don't drain well can compromise the effectiveness of a porous pavement system. While drainage channels or a layer of crushed stone can sometimes help, in certain cases, conventional alternatives may be a better choice.

Selecting the right material for a parking lot is no small task. Each option, whether it's traditional asphalt and concrete, the rustic appeal of gravel, tar and chip, or the environmentally sustainable permeable pavers, carries a unique set of advantages and challenges. Factors like the installation process, cost, maintenance needs, durability, and environmental impact all come into play.

Ultimately, the material that best suits your parking lot will hinge on your specific requirements, budget, and expert advice from your chosen contractor. This guide aims to provide valuable insights into different parking lot materials, aiding your decision-making process. Remember, a well-executed parking lot can enhance your property's value and serve your needs effectively for years to come.

Request An Estimate

Please complete the form below for a free no-obligation estimate.

crossmenu linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram